刮痧观后感

时间:2024.3.19

GuaSha is a movie about the differencesculture between American and Chinese. Xu datong is a games designer in St. Louis. When his father visits American he performs GuaSha on his grandson, which leaves some red scar on the back and causes a lawsuit of child abuse. Datong loses his mind so that he loses custody of his sonfinally. I think this scene is weird to most of the Chinese audiences. But the most impressing things to me is the end of the movie. Datong wants to see his son in Christmas eve, he has to climb a pipe to the ninth floor which his son lives. I think the pipe is not only a pipe, but also a difference between American and Chinese culture. He wants to climb over the it and he will never succeed, perhaps no Chinese people really could succeed.


第二篇:《刮痧》英文观后感多篇整理


第一篇

Chinese immigrants struggle to hold onto their American dream after the husband's father (Xu Zhu) comes for a visit from mainland China and gives a simple Chinese Medicine therapy called Gua Sha to his grandson.

Da Tong (Tony Leung Ka Fai) is the father who is trying to integrate his Chinese cultural beliefs into his daily American reality, especially when dealing with his boss (Hollis Huston) and best friend, who is too quick to believe the worst about Da Tong's treatment of his son, Dennis. Da Tong's failures show his confusion about the

differences between his original Chinese culture and his new American home. Even within his family there is conflict because Grandfather can't speak English and is excluded from many conversations because Mother (Wenli Jiang) wants only English spoken in her home for the benefit of her American born son. Da Tong and his wife are very well educated and understand that their child's best chances for success in America, and for him not to experience the same troubles they've had during the past 8 years, are to speak without an accent. They even go so far as to insist the boy use a fork and knife instead of chopsticks, even when it's obvious they are still eating Chinese style food, served in the normal way: communal dishes for the food and smaller, individual rice bowls for each person. Mother seems a bit inflexible in her insistence on being as American as possible, while Da Tong's cultural leanings are just as strongly Chinese, although not by conscious choice.

Da Tong's love for his son is tested severely when Da Tong tries to balance it against respect for his boss. When Da Tong's son hits his boss' son, Da Tong insists on an apology that seems unnecessary and makes Da Tong look stubborn and uncaring. Da Tong gives his boy a light rap on the head when he refuses to apologize and the boy cries to his mother that the reason he hit his playmate was that the other boy called Da Tong stupid, one of many examples of doing the wrong thing to protect your family.

The conflict arising from doing the wrong thing out of love or respect for one's family or closest friends continues throughout the movie, and every way Da Tong turns, he finds failure and encounters both obvious and subtle forms of anti-Chinese racism. Even Chinese folklore about the Monkey King, Sun Wu Kong, that Da Tong

incorporates into a video game he designed is used to provoke his pride when he's vulnerable and fearing for the loss of his son. Da Tong is misunderstood by everyone, family, friend, and foe, even though he has only the best intentions, and he carries the responsibility quite heavily, making one wrong turn after another.

Gua Sha (The Treatment) shows how a person's cultural beliefs are so deeply set within oneself that it is usually impossible to examine why you do most anything,

from how you dress and talk to whom you love and respect and how you show it. The invisible nature of one's cultural beliefs also makes it difficult to impossible to explain yourself to others when questioned. Da Tong experiences an excruciatingly painful and difficult struggle while trying to protect his son, an ordeal that forces him to examine the validity of some of the most vital things he thought he knew about his identity, his Chinese culture, and the new American world he'd chosen as his home.

The movie showed me how normal it is for people to look for ways that their culture is superior to others' and how the misunderstandings arising from different cultural perspectives can seem very large, but can be nullified with simple, 2-sided explanations when people are willing to listen.

It appears this film is not readily available in the USA, but it's the best I've seen at highlighting the differences between American and Chinese culture. Parts of the movie's dialog are only in Chinese and I've yet to find a DVD with English subtitles, although it's easy to get the gist of what's going on during those short passages. The credits are a combination of Chinese and English, holding true to the integration of both worlds. I've noticed some important roles are not credited here on IMDb, such as Judge Horowitz, who was played by Alexander Barton.

第二篇(可作为素材)

Gua Sha is a movie about the differences between American and Chinese culture. Xu datong is a video games designer in St. Louis. When his father visits from China, he performs Gua Sha (a Chinese traditional treatment) on his grandson, which leaves bright red marks on the skin and causes a lawsuit of child abuse. In the court, Datong loses his mind so that finally he loses custody of his son. I think this scene is shocking and thought-provoking to most of the Chinese audiences. But the most impressing scene to me is the ending. Datong wants to see his son in Christmas eve, he has to climb a pipe to the ninth floor which his son lives. I think the pipe is not only a pipe, but also a gap, a deep gap between American and 5000-year Chinese culture. He wants to climb over the gap and he will never succeed, perhaps no Chinese people really could succeed.

第三篇

At first sight name, thought it was ethical film, Gua Sha, Chinese traditional medicine a craft, in the long river of 2000 years of history, has remained robust health in China's vast territory to survive, but one day, it appears in a free and democratic

American society, they have been misunderstood, so staged a family joys and sorrows, good news is that Tony Leung will perform the role of the father moving chord, Jiang Wenli also consistent screen image of the character is almost starred in, it is an

accurate grasp of as his wife's hate, love, heart-broken and distressed, but the roles of mother to play down a little a bit. When forced to separation as the conditions in exchange for a child, his wife resolutely, "fiercely" to turn "I agree!" When things forced to have to really want to leave her husband, the wife painfully holding her husband could not bear her husband a life . From her husband in court infuriated the enemy fall into the trap of others start to his wife's anger was crazy the last disheartened, like a wife to her husband in frustration ~ because she knew her

husband would let children of any performance from their own farther and farther. Tony Leung Ka Fai is on the inside can be cut off from their return to their side as long as the child's father, but played down the role of her husband, with things progressing with the film step by step to a climax, the court was 'the enemy' forced control do not live mood, for others accused him of being an irresponsible father angry, for others the desecration of China's traditional culture indignation! Matter to the negative direction, he blame his friends, hate the United States, is not compatible! Living in the U.S. eight years, has encountered many difficulties and hardships, the number of difficult and setbacks he endured, and upheld, but this time he could no longer compromise, he could stand up and resist! Stand up and fight! Because they take away is that their children, their own flesh and blood! So he's irrational behavior we are all understandable.

Film has a few bright spots, one of which is the father carrying a child on the road and the police chase, chasing so much as it is for our children, the children do not

understand anything, he felt fun, so the father can not care about anything, forgetting all the way to meet the children's joy! Only a car will eventually be stopped, their families have to face the nightmare still exist. Separated spouses, the child has finally returned home, but his father left, Father and Son can not meet, the wife went to see the decadent husband, along with drinking alcohol, so alcohol tingling throat

anesthesia body. They want to cry want to resist, but can not, and only if all of the grievances of all the anger inside the pharynx to the stomach.

Originally his father and grandfather would like to take the kids went back to China together, but the grandfather firmly said: can not be done! Life is this way, anything can happen, you hide are not immune to the.

Anything can happen, laying bare the untold stories behind this event! Can not escape can not hide, we are the love of his family, acceptance of all the misfortunes of our courage.

Because of love, the father dressed as Santa Claus, from the sewer climbed back to his own home. Fortunately, the story has a happy ending. He did not disappoint and regret.

The film is in the context of Western cultural differences, in addition to the

performance of his son can not be split between husband and wife's love, he also seen the Chinese people's moral integrity, but also a success.

第四篇

The scrapping of a good film, plot to true self-purity, let a person Joe coughlin,

cuirenleixia. Film deduce the human world of affection, love, friendship and to social harmony is yearning, meanwhile, desire, because of the difference of culture and cause cross-cultural communication failures also show incisively and vividly. The story happened in saint Louis Mississippi River - United States central city of datong, actor xu united for eight years, your career greater success and your family happiness, as a game developers, new developed game in the annual sales unblocked, industry awards on congress, he excitedly told everybody: I love the United States, my

American dream has come true. However, the next of something that happened made him awake, son Dennis fever in the stomach, first came to the United States grandpa due to look not to understand language on captions in English and use Chinese

traditional Chinese medicine therapy "gua sha" to heal, and grandson this just became xu datong a small accident after evidence of child abuse, court another unexpected witnesses and testimony that he baikouquan oilfield.the difficult arguing, eventually lost the son's custody. In order to let the old father saw going home on one side, xu datong grandson violate the law the boy from welfare homes "steal" out -- In order to let the son returned to happy family and forced and his wife separated, In order to get back to his son's gift and insane and robber fights, For the Christmas Eve and the family reunions and risking were dashed along pipeline risk resolutely climbed in the ninth floor of house...... Panning, let a person surging, cherishing, deeply thinking.

The scrapping of the performance of the Chinese people and American people's

differences, not only in sino-american laws and moral standards, etc, and conceptions, even touch legal theory, theory of TCM and so on many issues. Due to the differences of spacetime, caused the sino-us eastern and western culture and concept - the different performance for the behavior, and then the conflict. Differences from on time for, mainly for countries the contradiction between the traditional and modern, From the space for countries in the region, history, politics, economy and other reasons caused the differences between Chinese and western, characterized by traditional ethnic background of the spirit, cultural background and philosophical background, etc. So, on the analysis of the film, we can't only stay in specific story aspect, but from big cultural background, from a historical tradition analysis.

We first come from the cultural origin of respects, first of all, Chinese and western in philosophy are different, the western advocate of rationalism of positivism, its

medical - anatomy, is built on the philosophical thinking, so for "gua sha" the mouth of qi of learning is not understand, And the characteristics of Chinese philosophy is the "nature and humanity" is to explore the relationship between nature and humans. Confucian moral, teach how heavy humanities life; The evolution of the Taoist heavy universe, teach a person to adapt to nature. In the movie, we can see that court, when xu datong told them "gua sha" the principle, the presence of American performance, the judge could not understand his defense, supposing that he was in disorderly speak, even his attorney cannot in this respect understand him. Secondly, in the awareness in China is important group consciousness, pay attention to integral value, think people should do contribution for the family and society, While western stressed is

individualism, the pursuit of individual freedom, free thinking and choice. In the film we can also see that xu datong in order not to let the old father worry, how and wife painfully conceal things truth; In order to let the old father saw coming back on one side, the grandson how difficult the Dennis from welfare homes "steal" come out. Chinese is the importance of family ethics, they values everyone in the family social position, emphasize home of ideas and feelings. Western culture has been respect due to personal idea, they've accepted the independent spirit "education, and family

feelings is relatively weak. American parents quite respect child freedom of action, in big principle range, let children free development. Again, the Chinese people's mode of thinking is integrated, admit overall and things of widespread contact between man and nature, the pursuit of perfect and unified. Western thinking mode is analysis of type, this thinking culture group of form relatively formally, right, responsibility and identity of distribution orderly. So, for the Chinese people, American thinking seems apathy, do not speak human, Westerners believe that the Chinese thought obscure.

We again to see ideas cultural differences, it is deep cultural differences, for instance people values, ways of thinking, social mentality, aesthetic idea, etc. A man can in another culture life is very long time, grasp their language, understand their custom, but may not understand some of its values, xu datong is living an example. Because in the deep culture, xu datong represent remains China's traditional culture, which embodies the attitude of a woman, friends, view of view, etc. In view of things,

americans like to face the fact that his own viewpoint, and master reliable information. Thus we can see americans deal with problems to a fact-based others.hold. But

Chinese in the face of facts, human feelings seem more more important. In the movie, we can see court child welfare bureau of the individual evidence, please list out of one witness how persuasive, although the Chinese people feel some incredible, And xu datong described how love only his own son, but no strong evidence, In the film and a detail, is two boys, xu datong in nanning-guiyang-kunming orchid face dozen children

slap, he later in nanning-guiyang-kunming balaam said: "I hit a child is to show respect for you, which is for your face." Here, the eastern and western involved in children's attitude problem. Chinese children as a private property, is my raw belongs to me. Although xu datong think dozen children is to the friends of respect, but in Queensland orchid opinion, hitting is illegal, no matter who is playing. Americans believe that parents, children are equal, parents seldom for children to decide what things, but rather let its rely on own strength to work hard. Friend in view, both eastern and western cultures also contains a different meaning. Edward

Stewad&Milton Bennet such discusses American friends: "although americans keep many friendly unofficial ties, but they rarely have that kind of deep and sustain years. The relation between the ideal realm is American friendship, based on natural

occurrence, attraction and warm personal feelings basis. People choose my friends, at the same time, they also friends or relations and social work obligations separate." In China, the situation differently. Friends cultured is time longer the better, commitment, the more good. The ideal realm is for my best Pal, go through hell in refuse to die. To Chinese friend's great expectations, if you have difficulty, ought to donate whatever they can. When Abram convicts xu datong nanning-guiyang-kunming when hitting the child, xu datong accused nanning-guiyang-kunming LAN "I carried you as his friend, but still you in court betray me!" And rakkon orchid feels very grievance and don't understand: "I was just telling the truth just." Honesty is America's most basic one of the virtues of, you let an American lie also be equivalent to let him give up the basic values.

Sino-us differences in performance of the film, but also expressed cultural

assimilation, cultural fusion of a kind of yearning. Abram passed from Queensland Chinatown porcelain store, personal try "gua sha"; From xu datong get rid of shows, downstairs police, residents erupted wixh applause, from he climbed the ninth floor of the house, the house and the children of amram welfare leadership congratulated him holy happiness, welcome home, audiences seem to see the westerners preached the Chinese and western cultural barriers, began to approach of traditional Chinese

culture, and eventually conquered all human feelings. The end of the story is perfect, but also must not ignore the cultural difference side, which requires us to strengthen exchanges and communication, hope in the near future, a "datong" world really will appear in front of us!

更多相关推荐:
《刮痧》观后感

刮痧读后感电影刮痧是一部反映中美文化冲突的影片故事发生在美国中部密西西比河畔的城市圣路易斯来美已经八年的许大同事业有成家庭幸福他把在北京生活的老父亲接到美国同住一天五岁的儿子丹尼斯闹肚子发烧他的爷爷由于刚从北京...

《刮痧》观后感(英汉对照版)

观后感一GuaShaisamovieaboutthedifferencesbetweenAmericanandChinesecultureXudatongisavideogamesdesignerinStLou...

刮痧观后感

刮痧体现的中美文化差异刮痧这部电影讲述的是由刮痧疗法而引起的华人在美国一系列的矛盾冲突反映了中美文化的差异许大同在美国八年已经取得了一定的成就事业有成家庭幸福后来也把父亲接到美国生活一次许大同的儿子丹尼斯发烧肚...

《刮痧》观后感

刮痧观后感第二次看这部电影看完后感觉与第一次截然不同第一次纯粹是当作故事来看的看完感动一下就没了而这次它给我的感触很大尽管已是十年前的电影了它反应出的问题还是让人深思它讲述的是一种中国文化与外国文化法律起到冲突...

《刮痧》观后感

法律基础刮痧观后感刮痧观后感浅谈文化差异在法律中的体现与刚开始带来的作为作业的疲倦感不同刮痧这部电影虽然没有卖座的故事情节和精彩的大片场景但是围绕刮痧这一中国传统医疗方法演绎出了在美华人在两种迥异的文化交锋形成...

刮痧读后感

刮痧观后感刮痧是一部值得观看引人深思的电影电影里面所表现出的感情让我动容亲情友情爱情这三个经久不衰的话题都在影片中真实的流露出来这是我第三次观看这次电影随着年龄的增长看完电影的感受都有所不同这大概和自己生活中所...

刮痧英文观后感

ThedifferencesbetweenChineseandwesternculturesfromthemovieGuaShaThistermIhavetakenanelectivecourseonwesternculturea...

刮痧 观后感

刮痧观后感第一次听到刮痧这个名字以为这是一部有关中医学的影片原来是以刮痧作为本部影片的线索讲述中外文化之间的差异观看影片刮痧后深刻地感受到中外文化的差异如生活方式传统习俗传统价值观念等等对中国人在外国的生活所造...

刮痧 英文观后感 论文

TheDifferencesbetweenChineseandWesternCulturesFromthemovieGuaSha1IntroductionGuaShaisamovieaboutthediffer...

《刮痧》电影观后感资料搜集

电影简介电影刮痧故事简介故事发生在美国中部密西西比河畔的城市圣路易斯许大同梁家辉饰来美已经八年了是个事业有成的电脑程式设计师太太简宁蒋雯丽饰是房地产商夫妻两人与可爱的儿子丹尼斯朱小潜饰一起过着幸福甜美的生活并且...

刮痧英文观后感

ScrapeisindeedagoodfilmforustoseeWhenIwasseeingthefilmIwastouchedbyitswonderfulplotThefilmnarratesthatthemaincharac...

观《刮痧》有感

观刮痧有感刮痧一件在中国人看起来再平常不过的小事却因为中西方文化差异让一个幸福的家庭莫名其妙地卷入了一场荒谬的官司中电影刮痧讲述的就是这样一个故事主人公许大同怀揣着自己的梦想来到美国通过自己的努力终于在这片土地...

刮痧观后感(47篇)